Changing hot water to Heat Pump, what do I use for backup baseboard heat? (2024)

Welcome! Here are the website rules, as well as some tips for using this forum.

Need to contact us? Visit https://heatinghelp.com/contact-us/.

Click here to Find a Contractor in your area.

802Abell Member Posts: 4

August 9 edited August 10 in THE MAIN WALL

I reside in Vermont, and currently use a wood pellet stove as my primary heat source. I have a #2 fuel oil furnace being used for hot water and is available for backup baseboard heat. Over the course of 9 years I have only used the baseboard heat once, which was for about 8 days while waiting for a replacement part for the pellet stove. I have a family of 6 in the house, and 2 in an in-law apartment. The in-law apartment has it's own heating sources and only uses the hot water from the main house. I am ready to make a change for multiple reasons (to fix the awful plumbing install, to reduce the footprint in the basem*nt by removing the oil tank and furnace, to reduce the need for a chimney as it is leaking and failing).

I am considering installing a Rheem XE80T10HS45U0 (Electric Heat Pump Water Tank) for the hot water replacement.

What can I do for the backup baseboard hot water? As the baseboard heat is rarely used, could I install an electric on demand heater? I would assume that using the heat pump water tank with a heat exchanger would not work at all?

Thank you,

Ryan

Ironman Member Posts: 7,416
August 9

An electric on demand would require a very large circuit and possibly a service upgrade, not to mention that it’s not designed, controlled or approved for space heating.
An electric water tank only produces 15.3k btus per hour which no where near enough to heat the house. The same goes for a heat pump water heater.
You’ve got to think in terms of what’s needed if you stop using the pellet stove or if you have to sell the house.
A small mod-con boiler with an indirect water heater would be my recommendation. It would be propane powered.

Bob Boan
You can choose to do what you want, but you cannot choose the consequences.
1
Rich_49 Member Posts: 2,768
August 10

ve a look at this as opposed to the HPWH . At present HPWHs are suffering many failures for many reasons . With the amount of folks you have in the house it would be a bad idea also . Imagine having to schedule showers , laundry and when to do the dishes . They , well , quite frankly suck . The water heater I am linking to could easily handle your demand . As far as a backup boiler , I would lean toward something propane and as small as you'd require , it making domestic hot water would be optional . https://www.htproducts.com/everlast-elevate-demand-response.html

You didn't get what you didn't pay for and it will never be what you thought it would .

732-751-1560
Serving most of New Jersey, Eastern Pa .
Consultation, Design & Installation anywhere
Rich McGrath 732-581-3833
1
DCContrarian Member Posts: 367
August 10

Keep the fuel oil boiler for backup heat. And backup hot water if the heat pump fails.
1
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 10 edited August 10

are you using an oil domestic water heater as the central heater? Or is this a boiler connected to a separate tank (AKA an indirect)? Maybe a picture could help.

If an indirect - just keep the boiler as backup. You could also consider an air to water heat pump, which would heat both house and DHW (this option is more involved). A tankless water heater should never be installed unless you have zero room, which doesn’t apply here. If you’re considering electric resistance as backup, just directly installing electric baseboard is extremely reliable and easy. Just abandon the hydronic distribution entirely, although this option would cut off future heat pump central hydronic heating.

See Also
Choosing a Heat Pump | Enercare Heat pumps - everything you need to know | One Home Is my home suitable for a heat pump? A five-point checklist Heat Pump vs Air Conditioner: Which is Cheaper to Keep Your Home Cool?
Big Ed_4 Member Posts: 2,852
August 10

Back up heat only and to remove equipment … I thinking electric strip heaters
There was an error rendering this rich post.
802Abell Member Posts: 4
August 10

Thank you all! I appreciate the feedback regarding the Heat Pump Hot Water heaters, making me shy away from them, thank you.

I really want to remove the old boiler, to save space in the basem*nt (by removing furnace, oil tank and awful plumbing job) and to retire the failing chimney.
I like the electric baseboard option. I thought the Heat Pump Hot Water heater would be a cheaper and easier option than the propane install. The direct vent option of the propane furnace will eliminate the chimney, and relocating to a different wall in the basem*nt will allow a fresh plumbing installation as well.
I’ve attached a picture of the existing
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 10

You cannot use a heat pump water heater (like a Rheem, AO Smith, etc. - one that is not connected to the outdoors and is built to heat DHW) to heat a house. Full stop. It operates by taking heat from the house to heat the water. You would, in effect, turn an extremely efficient heater into an extremely inefficient heater, plus it’d be too small either way. A HPWH is a great way to heat domestic hot water though!
Electric baseboard would delete the boiler (not furnace) and all hydronic tubing but you would still have a tank. Either a HPWH or a plain electric resistance tank would solve the chimney problem. A propane boiler would also be more compact. The issue with electric baseboard is that you might be cutting it close with electric service space.

1
Jamie Hall Member Posts: 23,763
August 10

There's another problem with electric resistance baseboard, besides very likely having to upgrade your service entrance and electrical panel. Money. Not just in running the thing — electric resistance heat is the most expensive option that you could possibly have — but resale on the house. Unless this is your forever home, a buyer is going to look at all electric resistance heat and suddenly become very reluctant…
Br. Jamie, osb
Building superintendent/caretaker, 7200 sq. ft. historic house museum with dependencies in New England
2
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 11

Agreed but this is a seldom used backup. Probably does make sense to pay more in operating costs and cheap install costs vs paying much more for an oil boiler that probably is slightly cheaper to operate.
Steamhead Member Posts: 17,055
August 11
See Also
Smoothing the Transition to Heat Pumps — Part 1: Code Changes

Keep the boiler and hydronic baseboard. That's a good boiler and will serve well with proper care. Use the heat pump unless it gets down past freezing, then fire up the boiler.
That boiler can also be changed to gas firing using a Carlin EZ-Gas burner.

All Steamed Up, Inc.
Towson, MD, USA
Steam, Vapor & Hot-Water Heating Specialists
Oil & Gas Burner Service
Consulting
DCContrarian Member Posts: 367
August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807777#Comment_1807777
Relatedly, insurance companies have become increasingly reluctant to insure houses with solid fuel burning appliances. And increasingly insistent that the house have a thermostat-controlled heating system as well so the pipes don't freeze if the owner isn't able to keep the fire going for some reason.
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 11

Use the heat pump unless it gets down past freezing, then fire up the boiler.
@Steamhead I think there’s confusion. We’re talking about a domestic hot water heat pump. I don’t think we’ve even broached the subject of a central heating heat pump.
pecmsg Member Posts: 4,986
August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807782#Comment_1807782
the OP did state he wanted to free up space by getting rid of the boiler and oil tank.
Big mistake in my book!

1
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 11

I think a tank for DHW is almost always the answer.
802Abell Member Posts: 4
August 11

I would like to keep a DWH tank, especially with the number of members in the household. Priority one is to eliminate the need for the chimney, as it is leaking and would rather put the cost of chimney repairs towards a different heating system. Priority two is to reduce the footprint of the current heating system in the house (fuel oil tank, existing plumbing mess).
Vermont’s current rebate on heat pump water heaters put me down the path of thinking about installing one. With the need for backup heat the heat pump water heater doesn’t seem like an option. The current boiler that I have could be converted to direct vent propane???
pecmsg Member Posts: 4,986
August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807799#Comment_1807799
who said that boiler could be converted to direct vent?

are you planing on taking down that chimney?
Hot_water_fan Member Posts: 1,941
August 11

I think there’s much confusion here: the HPWH doesn’t need any sort of backup, but it is limited to DHW.
1
802Abell Member Posts: 4
August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807801#Comment_1807801
There was mention of converting to gas firing using a Carlin EZ-Gas burner. With that, would that allow for direct vent?

Yes, will be removing the chimney.
pecmsg Member Posts: 4,986
August 11 edited August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807803#Comment_1807803
depending on the age of that boiler you might be better off going with a 96% LP condensing boiler

1
HVAcnu*t Member Posts: 5,932
August 11

https://forum.heatinghelp.com/discussion/comment/1807775#Comment_1807775
You've got a Weil Mclain GO cast iron, wet base boiler. Yes, it needs to be properly piped, but the boiler itself should last. And any reputable service tech would have any replacement part in the truck.
A new oil tank can be installed, slab on grade, outside. Again, it must be properly set and piped. And use a good fuel additive.
What specifically is wrong with the chimney? Has it been inspected, and recommendations made?
You could go with LPG and a mod con, but do the math first.
A good 2 Stage or inverter type heat pump is not an unwise decision IMO, but for myself, it would never be my sole heat source. My situation is similar to yours, and I'll upgrade my oil boiler. I'll also upgrade my 20 year old R22 system to a 2 Stage heat pump. The hydronic baseboard heat will be Stage 3. The boiler will still provide DHW.

Changing hot water to Heat Pump, what do I use for backup baseboard heat? (2024)

Categories